So it's been a lonely year or so bobbing In The Water by myself. Though the multi-author function on Typepad is a little rich for my blood at the moment, that won't stop me from sticking up pieces, rants, observations etc. from other people around here! So, feel free to contribute something to my email address. Meanwhile, ladies and gentlemen, our first guest contributor, Sunshine Wong, offers us her direct experiences with WTO head Pascal Lamy and his crew... enjoy!
Tonight i was at a dinner organised by the FCC [Foreign Correspondent's Club- PT] - a friend had an invitation addressed "to the hong kong civil society" (whose prerequisite was also "caucasian", as it became apparent upon our arrival) - and the event was basically a meet-the-WTO director session for the creme de la creme of hong kong armchair reporters. i had no idea that such a world existed, or rather, its existence was for me so much based on hearsay since i refuse outright to associate myself with irresponsible journalists - but anyway. that's not the point. unless the point was overhearing a conversation taking place to the right of me (pun intended). Pre-talk, i hear:
- "I don't need to haul 18 plastic mugs of coffee into china's hinterland when i do reporting there now, what with the internationalisation. it's great!"
- "But there are still no dunkin' donuts."
- "Foreigners will always be made to feel foreign in china whereas, i think, other people immigrating to america will ultimately become american."
- "Well, there will always be winners and losers in such a large scale trade.
- "The vocal minority of people who are on the short end of the stick make such a huge racket."
And m. Pascal Lamy echoes:
"... yet the majority who benefit from trade are largely silent. the minority who are hurt by trade - and there are those who are hurt - are anything but silent and they are extremely active
politically. you will be hearing from this not-so-silent minority often in the weeks to come."
I like that the minority are billions of people whose lives have been uprooted and irreversibly damaged by free trade.
My stance as an art teacher with little political involvement made it all the more difficult to situate myself within that context, surrounded by "hong kong's civil society" who were all white, over 40, and chewing on the ends of their pens, wiping their gold framed glasses, or scribbling away on pads. Apparently the articulation of the girl whose voice of protest at Lamy's meeting with NGOs yesterday wasn't convincing, thereby rendering her arguments and opinions inconsequential. I guess lamy's bald head and calculated vocabulary and feigned mediation role he plays and all that would equal "articulate".